Archived under: Narcissism & negativity, Teaching | Stories
The Provocative Teacher
"Hey, you better straighten out kiddo, or this is all you'll amount to - HA HA HAAA!!"
I don’t particularly like to do this, but occasionally I encounter a student that absolutely needs to be poked with a stick. Repeatedly. The usual approaches and methods don’t seem to motivate them like the other students.
One such student long ago had high ambitions to be a Hollywood studio horn player. As a challenge, I threw the massive Arban trumpet encyclopedia in front of him to test his fingers and reading abilities. He failed – and we struggled for several weeks.
I finally realized that this student had been (and was still) involved in high school athletics. He had been accustomed to a more aggressive and confrontational style of learning. Once I adopted to his style, his learning improved.
The downside of this approach is that even longer ago, in a galaxy, far, far away, I accidentally provoked a student to tears. I had completely misread his demeanor and this provocation was too much.
I am always cautious when testing these waters for fear of being a domineering autocrat – or a mean teacher.
- Have you needed to get in a student’s face in order to motivate them?
- What are your afterthoughts to this approach?
Related to this article
- The Ego-Driven Music Teacher: Good or Bad? (II)
Continued from Part I The ego-driven approach to music instruction reminds me of the used car salesman whose opening sale pitch was that their company sold thousands of cars each month. He rattled on and on to me with successful sales quotes and impressive statistics. Finally,... - The Modern Horn Teacher
I recently had a question posed to me about classic and modern horn teaching methods. In terms of myself, I aim to be practical and effective –I believe my approach is a hybrid between the two extremes. To my mind the ultimate “classic” horn teacher would... - The Ego-Driven Music Teacher: Good or Bad? (I)
Teaching — more art than science? I occasionally lurk — read, but do not participate in — the various horn discussion groups. Interesting topics come up that in turn inspire blog topics. An underlying subtext that appears every now-and-then is ego-driven authority and opinion. Some teachers... - The Mean Horn Teacher
One style of horn teaching is to be the mean teacher. It is supposed to motivate students, and there will perhaps always be some “old school” teachers of this type out there. Often this approach is a part of a “my way or the highway” strategy... - Friedrich Gumpert, Master Teacher of the Horn
Often hornists will look back on their “genealogy” in terms of who their teachers were, the teachers of their teachers, etc. A number of my teachers were Farkas students and I took several lessons with Farkas directly, so this would be a major influence if I... - Selecting a Horn Teacher
It is that time of year; many students are right now in the final process of making their comparisons of offers from schools for advanced horn study. It is a complicated thing, choosing a school. There are so many elements to consider. Speaking generally I feel... - Dennis Brain Illustrated
In the process of learning a new illustration technique, I have been using images of great horn players from the past as practice. This image is used without permission, so if someone official objects to me making their picture look too super-cool, I would have no...
The Holton VD Mouthpiece
Review: Using Tooble to Download YouTube Videos
The Most Insane and Crazy Carmen Story Ever - Part II
