Don’t Sweat Marching Band – Part 2


In the first installment of this article we looked at alternate instruments to use in Marching Band that will save your chops and blood pressure. But the cold, hard truth is that in most bands you’re going to have to use a regular Mellophone in lieu of some newfangled Marching Horn that takes a normal Horn mouthpiece.

 Don’t Sweat Marching Band – Part 2Fear not. These little beasts are not to be feared, or even disliked. Actually, Horns and Mellophones can coexist quite pleasantly if you allow them to. A good Mellophone can become quite the guilty pleasure.

What will make your experience with your Mellophone change from bad to good boils down to your mouthpiece. There have been many breakthroughs in mouthpiece development to where they expect horn players will be using the horn, so the mouthpieces are designed with horn players in mind, specializing in a V-shaped cup which will give you a more French Horn-like experience..

Before we even go down that road, all Mellophones usually come with a horn mouthpiece adapter. Yes, they can be used in pinch, but there’s normally some sort of compromise – usually with tone or intonation.

Karl Hammond has designed their Mellophone mouthpieces specifically with horn players in mind so their transition will be seamless. Their mouthpieces are the most widely used by the top 12 Drum Corps. Additionally, the IYM, though a heavyweight, has the internal feel of a horn mouthpiece, and many bands and corps have adopted them. Another very popular mouthpiece is the Curry 1HTF. Okay, it’s actually a trumpet mouthpiece, but internally it, too, is more like a horn mouthpiece.

More important than what mouthpiece you use is what mouthpiece NOT to use. Though a Mellophone CAN use a trumpet mouthpiece, they absolutely should NOT use one. Trumpet mouthpieces are designed for the trumpet. End of story.

Also, avoid the Mello 6. Finally, as a rule, don’t use the mouthpiece that comes with the horn.

All in all, with proper care and hardware, Marching Season shouldn’t stress you out in any way. Enjoy the experience and, above all, make peace with your instrument.

articles: Middle brass enthusiast Alan "Al" Perkins is host of The Mellocast and owner of Al's Mellophone Page and Al's Tenor Horn Page.

Related to this article


  • Don’t Sweat Marching Band – Part 1
    Nothing strikes fear and stress into the hearts of any horn player like Marching Band. Horn players on the whole tend to be hypersensitive when it comes to hitting the field. But don’t fret, little marcher. There are plenty of ways to survive marching season without...
  • Thoughts on Marching Band Contest
    I was able to hear part of marching band contest at ASU today. A horn major is one of the co-drum majors in the ASU marching band this year and I keep hearing good things about the group. So today I heard a chunk of the...
  • I Just got in a Drum Corps, What Mouthpiece Should I Use?
    I have been asked this question twice recently, and I know that this is one that comes up for horn teachers and players often. The first suggestion is don’t use a Mello 6 or any similar mouthpiece if possible. The plain fact is this is just...
  • What is a Good Tone on a Mellophone?
    Here is a topic that you won’t see often in a horn blog—tone on the mellophone. I have a very clear idea of what a good horn tone is. A big part of my horn teaching is working with students to develop their best sound. One...
  • Mellophone Mouthpiece FAQ
    Ummm…mellophone mouthpieces? Funny how jet lag can just hit you. I thought I was doing well from the travel back from Taiwan, then, wham! Last night, instead of sleeping, I spent quite a while thinking about mellophone mouthpieces. Besides also doing an update on my list...
  • The B-flat Marching Horn
    While I have posted on this topic in my main site, one topic I have not posted on in the blog specifically is the B-flat marching horn. There is certainly confusion out there as to how this instrument might be used in groups, how it is...
  • Mouthpiece Update for 2008
    Readers seem to always be curious about mouthpieces, so an update is in order. I have several concerts coming in the next month [Feb, 2008], and for them I have settled into the following. Horn: While I still play double horn in lessons often, in reality...

Comments ()


John Ericson & Bruce Hembd
on the French horn, brass related topics, and the field of classical music.