Can You Play Trumpet and Horn?
I received a question from a reader that noted I taught horn and trumpet when I taught in Taiwan for a year. He was asking what I did in terms of mouthpieces and doubling? This type of question comes up pretty often and I don’t believe I have put anything down about it yet. What I did to teach trumpet was really easy on my horn embouchure; I did not play trumpet at all that year. I played every example I played for any student in a trumpet lesson on the horn. I have not performed more than just a few random notes on a trumpet since 9th grade. I really do not sound good at all on trumpet at this point.
The short answer to the question is in my opinion this double cannot be done. The embouchure is really different. The player attempting to do this will find that on the horn they have a tight, harsh tone; this is because the “center of gravity” of their embouchure is too high. The horn really requires a lot of low range work to be played with a great, characteristic tone. When you have the embouchure at that place where the horn sounds really good you will sound just awful on trumpet, with a very “soggy” tone and even the mid range feels really high and difficult.
I know there are quite a few people out there that try to do it, to double trumpet and horn. I am sure that there are people who claim that it can be done too. There are probably even teachers who think trumpet playing might help develop the high range of their horn students. But to try to double the two instruments is very hard on a low level and, in my opinion, impossible on a high level. To achieve a high level of performance, you will need to pick one and develop an embouchure around the range of that instrument.
UPDATE: For a different perspective–that it can be done–read this article by Tom Varner. I have played a little trumpet these past few years (methods class and in teaching a beginner) and it is interesting, I can reach a reasonably high level on the instrument. I prefer using a mouthpiece with a horn inner diameter on it, a Curry 1HTF to be specific.
Related to this article
- What Horn Players Think About Trumpet Players
This week I led a brass sectional with the ASU Symphony Orchestra brass section. At the end of the sectional I was asked I believe jokingly by a trumpet player a question something like “what do horn players think about trumpet players.” At first I gave... - The Horn Problem
Different people will have different opinions as to what the “horn problem” is (or if there is a problem). Talking this past weekend with other teachers in Arizona, however, it is even clearer to me that for Arizona anyway part of the problem is the low... - Quote of the Week–Hill on High Range
High range development is a topic that comes up with every horn student, and every horn teacher has his or her ideas as to the most effective ways to improve the high range. These comments are from Douglas Hill, Professor of horn at the University of... - Two Baroque Horn Concertos that Should be Performed More Often
If a Baroque concerto is heard, it is most often the Telemann or maybe the Forster. These are fine works but there are alternates that really should be played more often, they are better works than a lot of the music trumpet players perform from the... - The Two Approaches to the Horn Embouchure
The description of the embouchure as described by Philip Farkas is well known. However, one fact, little spoken in the horn community, is there are essentially two approaches to the embouchure, one that Farkas describes and another described by Gunther Schuller and others. Read the two...
Food for Thought, A Recipe For Success
'Answers' to the Names on the Who's Who Survey
A Very French Villanelle
A Tale of Cover Stock
Photograph: Study in contrast, II
Exercise: Scale/Flow Studies (I)
Random Monday: Mooing, bumping and stressing out
